Food and the Final Frontier: How Researchers Intend to Grow Plants in Space
By Lee Allen 29 September 2017
Takeaway: As humans look to colonize distant planets in our solar system and beyond, work has begun on figuring out a way to feed those willing to make the trip both during their travels and once settled. Lee Allen takes us closer to one program experimenting with controlled-environment growing for space travel.
It’s all about Point A and Point B, staying alive while travelling massive distances and remaining alive once you reach your destination—say Mars or other as-yet-undiscovered sites in the solar system.
According to th Universe Today, depending on orbital rotation, the average distance between Earth and Mars is approximately 140 million miles. Even travelling at well over 35,000 miles per hour, such a trip could take up to eight months. Hence, the need for the Mars-Lunar Greenhouse project at the University of Arizona’s Controlled Environment Agriculture Center in Tucson, a fully functional prototype greenhouse that has been growing crops for years under the auspices of a NASA Steckler Space Grant collaboration.
The edibles—everything from strawberries to sweet potatoes, peanuts, and peppers—are of the type that could grow on a trip to the moon or the Red Planet. They’re housed in a large cylinder that would ride along with either robots or astronauts on their extended journey.
Because a hydroponic system and a controlled-environment grow area can provide yields of up to 10 times higher than an open field, feeding a crew of space explorers for months on end isn’t just science fiction. That kind of ingenuity is already being applied to earthbound applications, such as enhancing global food security and providing fresh, locally grown food to large urban centres.
“Growing ‘Martian food’ is our day job,” says horticultural engineer Gene Giacomelli, co-principal investigator for the grant that reached a tentative terminus last month. “At some point, people will travel to, live, and work on another planet, and when they do, they’ll need to grow their own food. That’s what we do here every day.”
Or did. The grant funding was depleted at the end of September. “We’ve been cobbling money together piecemeal since 2000,” says Giacomelli. That’s when NASA considered about 20 proposals for grant funds and the CEAC Extreme Climate Laboratory received about $70,000 from the Ralph Steckler Space Grant Colonization Research and Technology Development program to get started. In Phase 2 funding, the University of Arizona made the shortlist for $250,000, with another $275,000 that followed in Phase III.
“When we first applied, we sent data and photos of how our controlled-environment unit was already built and working, so we requested to be allowed to continue and expand our effort,” says Giacomelli. “We took the capabilities of hydroponics, controlled environments, and their computerization and put it together in a format that created an 18-foot-long by an 8-foot-diameter structure that is lightweight—300 pounds when empty—and in a cylindrical shape that NASA could appreciate.”
The unit can be auto-deployed and tended to by a robot. It’s collapsible and stable so it can be shipped, and in the distant future, be automatically deployed anywhere before human beings from this planet arrive to inhabit a distant land. Once landed, the unit would activate itself, inflate, and water would be turned on to start seeds sprouting.
This is a robust fibre factory, a very workable food production unit. “You could call it a Food Robot if you want to because it’s automated,” says Giacomelli. We’ve developed a control system that turns it on and off with minimal work required from any living being. In fact, we only go inside once a week for an hour to harvest nutrient-rich crops filled with vitamins and minerals.”
Each technological advancement became a stepping stone to the next. “We could show how much effort, cost, and need for automation was required to make this food system most efficient to the point that it used minimal resources and could function on another planet.”
Sadler Machine Company built the lunar greenhouse. Phil Sadler is a veteran of prototype production, having previously built CEAC’s South Pole Growth Chamber, where many ideas used in the lunar greenhouse were developed. The South Pole grow structure supplies fresh food to the research station that is cut off from the outside world for half a year at a time, so production, recycling, and an efficient use of resources are just as important at the South Pole operation as they will be on other planets.
The use-it-up-and-then-use-it-again concept is imperative. For instance, a dozen 1,000W sodium vapour lights generate a lot of heat, which can then be siphoned away by each lamp’s cooling system and used to heat the station. Their goal is to minimize labour needs, reduce resource use, and recycle everything to operate as efficiently as possible.
The lunar greenhouse contains about 220 pounds of wet plant material that provides several dozen quarts of potable water and close to a pound of oxygen during a 24-hour period.
As they close out the NASA contract, Giacomelli says, “Here’s a workable structure, or rather, a possible series of four structures joined by an interconnecting hallway. Phil’s contention was that you don’t generally send one astronaut, but perhaps four, so that each one of these capsules can supply half the calories, as well as oxygen and fresh water, for one astronaut on a daily basis.”
The prototype is covered with a specialized polyethylene commercially available in greenhouses. “We just used it to create an envelope around our crop production. Someone else will have to develop a thick durable multi-layer material to surround the unit, like a space suit for veggies instead of people.”
There are many lessons learned, including, surprisingly, an “aha!” moment involving esthetics more than pure science.
“Our greenhouse validated the importance of fresh vegetable colors that can’t be duplicated and the effects of a green plant or a ruby red fruit, like a tomato or a strawberry, for people living and working in an extreme environment such as space,” Giacomelli says.
“Think of the fact that they’ll be living in a contraption, an artificially-lit structure where they’ll seldom see the sun. Here, they can go into a garden space, which is also their food and water supply, their life support, and it gives them psychological benefits. Even as we automated the process, people still want that connection to be part of the cycle… to touch the plants and breathe in the aromas in an otherwise lifeless environment.”
Adds Sadler, “Humans can go into the growth chamber and smell vegetables and flowers and see living green things… a necessity to break up the monotony of thousands of square miles of the desolate terrain surrounding their completely man-made environment.”
With good science developed over the life of the Mars-Lunar Greenhouse Project and so many questions remaining to be answered, it seems a shame to just power it down and let the plants shrivel. But that’s one potential reality.
“Do we just give up?” asks Giacomelli. “I don’t think so. We may not move ahead of the way NASA had wanted us to, but we still have a large-scale laboratory for others who have ideas on how to improve such a system. We know how to stretch dollars, so it’s not like we’re disappearing completely. We’ve got Band-Aids we can apply to keep the lights and power on, like a small grant from Philips Lighting Company to put their LEDs in the chamber, but if we have to shut down, major reconstructive surgery would have to await further funding.
“Turning things off today would be like setbacks in the mid-1990s, where it took 15 to 20 years for groups to start to put the pieces back together again. We created a whole operating system that is in jeopardy of continuation in the short term because there’s no one stepping forward to pick up that ball,” says Giacomelli.
As Godfather to the operation, Giacomelli is stoic. “This is my baby and you want all babies to grow up and succeed as much as possible. I’m proud that we moved the ball forward, and there’s enough information we’ve developed so the idea won’t be lost. This is a child that had a unique childhood, grew up and got its first job, started being productive—and then got laid off. It’s waiting for a new job opportunity to present itself.”
Systems engineer and principal technical investigator for the project, Roberto Furfaro, adds, “We’ve been in similar situations before where we phased down to a minimum to keep things working while we looked for future funding to continue the project and return to full research status.”
While there has been a lot of talks, but no commitment to this point, discussions continue with the HI-SEAS project in Hawaii, a simulated Mars base camp where astronauts wear protective suits over extended time periods. “They are mission-oriented, rather than worrying about life support systems,” Furfaro says, “but if consideration turned to the element of food production, there’s a possibility that one of our chamber units could be included in their program.”
Even as the LED and high-pressure sodium lamps are being turned down to dim in the Arizona desert lab, similar programs are underway elsewhere in the world.
Giacomelli is an advisor to the German Space Agency EDEN greenhouse project (a part of the European Space Agency) for a demonstration Mars-Lunar structure being constructed in the extreme environment of Antarctica where a researcher will live there for a year starting in January to further demonstrate the viability of such a food production unit.
“These researchers will be using technology we developed during our grant,” he says.
That technology is expected to also play a part in the European Space Agency’s project in Spain where they have also put together a closed food production facility.
Food and the future are also centre stage in China where four students are already living in something called the Lunar Palace.
“I saw it before they closed the doors and sealed off the researchers to experiment with food production and waste recycling,” Giacomelli says. “They’ll be gaining a lot of practical, real-person, real-time experience that we are not able to do now.”